2025 Precedential Opinions

Over the past four years, the Board has issued between 30 and 38 precedential rulings per year. In 2025, the Board issued 11. One might ask, why the drop-off?

Section 2(d) - Likelihood of Confusion:

• Precedential No. 11: TTAB Awards Section 44(d) Priority to Domiciliary of British Virgin Islands Based on Reciprocity, Grants Summary Judgment Motion Contingent on Ultimate Registration
• Precedential No. 10: TTAB Explains How to Submit Video Evidence, Reverses 2(d) Refusal of GASPER ROOFING Over JASPER CONTRACTORS
• Precedential No. 7: Opposer Fails to Prove Distinctiveness of its Common Law Mark, Loses 2d Opposition on Priority

Lack of Bona Fide Intent:

• Precedential No. 9: Affirming GASPARILLA Section 2(d) Refusal, TTAB Rejects Flimsy Consent Agreement
• Precedential No. 8: TTAB Shuts Down "THE HOTEL EL ROBLAR" Application Due to Lack of Bona Fide Intent
• Precedential No. 4: TTAB Sustains Opposition to CUADRA for Alcoholic Beverage Due to Lack of Bona Fide Intent

Entitlement to a Statutory Cause of Action:

• Precedential No. 2: TTAB Sustains Section 14(3) Opposition to LA MONTSERRATINA for Meat Products Based on Reputation in USA Without Use

Discovery/Evidence/Procedure:

• Precedential No. 6: TTAB Refuses to Add Affirmative Defense of Abandonment but Allows Addition as Counterclaims
• Precedential No. 3: Dismissal with Prejudice but Without Judgment Suffices for Claim Preclusion Defense

Prosecution Issues:

• Precedential No. 5: TTAB Will Not Accept Incorporation-By-Reference of An Appellant's Prosecution Arguments
• Precedential No. 1: TTAB Upholds USPTO Objections to Over-Inclusive Drawings for Watch Configuration Marks

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2025.

TTABlog Running Index: October 2025 to Date

E-mail subscriptions to the TTABlog are available. Just enter your e-mail address in the box on the right to receive a daily update via Feedblitz. Please report any broken or inoperative links, as well as any errors and omissions, to the TTABlogger at jwelch at wolfgreenfield.com.

Section 2(d) - Likelihood of Confusion:

• TTABlog Test: Is BLACKTHORN for Construction Management SAAS Confusable with BLACKTHORNE for Computer-Based Information Systems Consulting? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• On Remand, TTAB Again Denies Petition to Cancel BABIE'S MAGIC TEA Registration: Confusion Unlikely with BABY MAGIC for Skincare Products
• TTABlog Test: Is WISHBONES for a Casino Bar Confusable with WISHBONE FARMS for Restaurant Services? [Yes]
• TTAB Denies SMARTLING/EASYLING Cancellation Petition for Translation Software Due to Differences in Marks, Purchaser Sophistication, and Lack of Actual Confusion

• Precedential No. 11: TTAB Awards Section 44(d) Priority to Domiciliary of British Virgin Islands Based on Reciprocity, Grants Summary Judgment Motion Contingent on Ultimate Registration
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTAB Grants Petition to Cancel RAFT Registration for Computer Game Software Based on Prior Trademark Use and Analogous Use
• TTABlog Test: Two Section 2(d) Refusals of THE JILLY BOX: How Did the Appeal Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: Is DANKE Confusable with MERCI for Chocolates? [No]
• Again Finding Wine Related to Whiskey, TTAB Upholds Refusal of ALTAMURA DISTILLERIES & Design Over ALTAMURA
• TTABlog Test: Is TRIFOX for Bicycle Forks Confusable With FOX for Bicycle Shock Absorbers? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is DUO for Personal Mobility Devices Confusable with DUOPOWER for Land Vehicles? [Yes]
• Precedential No. 10: TTAB Explains How to Submit Video Evidence, Reverses 2(d) Refusal of GASPER ROOFING Over JASPER CONTRACTORS

• Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Reversed?
• TTABlog Test: Are T-Shirts and Hats Related to Toy Action Figures Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is TROOMY for Supplements Confusable with TROOP for Mushroom-Containing Supplements? [No]
• Two Recent Section 2(d) Oppositions Sustained by the TTAB
• TTAB Dismisses Section 2(d) Opposition to HABANA BRISA: not Confusable with HAVANA TAN! for Sun Care Preparations
• TTAB Reverses VERSAMAX Section 2(d) Refusal: Applicant's Specific Tractors not Related to Trailers, Purchasers Careful
• On Remand, TTAB Reverses Course, Sustains Section 2(d) Opposition to ECHO D'ANGELUS for Alcoholic Beverages and Wine
• Precedential No. 9: Affirming GASPARILLA Section 2(d) Refusal, TTAB Rejects Flimsy Consent Agreement
• TTABlog Test: Is "1849 BOURBON" for Distilled Spirits Confusable With "1849" for Wine? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Which One of These Four Section 2(d) Appeals Was Successful?
• TTABlog Test: Is KARMA KRACKERS for Crackers Confusable with KARMA for Nuts? [Yes]
• Weakness of "BNB" Brings Cancellation Denial: "COMPLETE BNB" Not Confusable with "AIRBNB"

Section 2(e)(1) - Mere Descriptiveness:

• TTABlog Test: Is "MUSIC.AI" Merely Descriptive of Music Production Software? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is HOLY HABITS Merely Descriptive of Spiritual Growth Management Software? [Yes]
• TTAB Finds PALAPA to be Merely Descriptive of Event Venue Services
• TTAB Orders Cancellation of STORIES OF THE PROPHETS Registration, Finding it Merely Descriptive of Religious Books
• SHIPPERCOPILOT Merely Descriptive of AI Software Services for Facilitating Shipping, Says TTAB
• TTABlog Test: Is "TAC-O" Merely Descriptive of Food Seasonings and Cooking-Related Services?

Section 2(e)(2) - Primarily Geographically Descriptive:

• TTABlog Test: Is RODEO TEXAS Primarily Geographically Descriptive of Sports Event Parties and Non-rodeo Clothing? [Yes]
• TTAB Grants Petition to Cancel ZIGONG LANTERN GROUP Registration due to Geographical Descriptiveness

Section 2(f) - Acquired Distinctiveness:

• TTAB Deems Bottle Trade Dress a Mere Refinement of Existing Designs and so Not Inherently Distinctive

Abandonment:

• TTAB Denies Petition for Cancellation of FAT KATZ Registration for Failure to Prove Abandonment

Genericness:

• VETEMENTS AG Files Reply to USPTO's Certiorari Opposition: TTABlog Asks, What About the Perception of 99 Percent of American Purchasers as to Genericness?
• PT Medisafe Files Certiorari Petition Seeking to Overturn CAFC Green Medical Glove Genericness Ruling

Nonownership:

• TTAB Denies Cancellation of "WHY PAY A LOT FOR STORAGE?" Registration, Rejecting Non-Ownership Claim

Nonuse:

• TTAB Orders Cancellation of EDGE GAMES Registration Due to Nonuse, Rejecting Founder's Testimony

Request for Information:

• TTAB Affirms Refusal of PARKAI Application for Failed Response to Rule 2.61(b) Request for Information

Statutory Standing:

• Organization for Transformative Works Files Amicus Brief Supporting Grant of Certiorari in RAPUNZEL Standing Case
• Professor Curtin Files Petition for Certiorari in RAPUNZEL Consumer Standing Case
• TTAB Denies Petition to Cancel Registration of President XI Likeness Due to Lack of Statutory Standing
• Opposer Fails to Submit Evidence: TTAB Dismisses for Failure to Prove Statutory Standing

Discovery/Evidence/Procedure:

• TTAB Upholds Three Refusals Because Applicant Provided its Counsel's Address, not its Domicile Address
• Anonymous Comment on Letters of Protest
• Precedential No. 10: TTAB Explains How to Submit Video Evidence, Reverses 2(d) Refusal of GASPER ROOFING Over JASPER CONTRACTORS

CAFC Decisions:

• CAFC Upholds TTAB: BASIN BEVERAGE CO. Confusable With TAHOE BASIN, GREAT BASIN COFFEE, and NEW BASIN DISTILLING COMPANY
• CAFC Upholds TTAB's Grant of Counterclaim for Cancellation: Applicant Proved Priority Through Assignment of Common Law Mark After Proceeding Commenced
• CAFC Reverses TTAB: KAHWA not Generic for, or Descriptive of, Cafés and Coffee Shops - Substantial Evidence Lacking

Recommended Reading:

• Recommended Reading: A Legal Strategist's Guide to Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Practice, Fifth Edition
• Recommended Reading: The Trademark Reporter, September-October 2025 Issue

Other:

• USPTO Publishes November 2025 Revision of the Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure
• Recent Supreme Court Developments in TTAB cases
• USPTO Seeks Applicants for Chief Administrative Trademark Judge at the TTAB
• Supreme Court Developments in TTAB cases
• TTAB Posts December 2025 Hearing Schedule
• TTAB Posts December 2025 Hearing Schedule
• TTABlog Celebrates 21st Anniversary!
• TTAB Posts November 2025 Hearing Schedule
• Judge Mary Beth Myles Has Resigned from the TTAB
• TTAB Quarterly Index: July - September 2025
• TTAB Posts October 2025 Hearing Schedule.

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2025.

TTABlog Quarterly Index: July - September 2025

E-mail subscriptions to the TTABlog are available. Just enter your e-mail address in the box on the right to receive a daily update via Feedblitz. Please report any broken or inoperative links, as well as any errors and omissions, to the TTABlogger at jwelch at wolfgreenfield.com.

Section 2(a) - False Connection:

• US SPACE FORCE Applicant Files Certiorari Petition Seeking Reversal of Section 2(a) False Connection Refusal

Section 2(d) - Likelihood of Confusion:

• Weakness of "MANE" for Hair Products Yields Dismissal: MAIN ESTEEM Not Confusable with MANE 'N TAIL
• Precedential No. 8: TTAB Shuts Down "THE HOTEL EL ROBLAR" Application Due to Lack of Bona Fide Intent
• TTABlog Test: Is M8KIT Confusable with M8 for Clothing? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• Cross-Fit Champion Mathew E. Fraser Wins Priority Contest Over HARD WORKS PAYS OFF Mark for Clothing
• TTABlog Test: Is "TASTE THE POETRY" for Vodka Confusable with "POETRY" for Wine? [Yes]
• CAMPANARIO for Alcoholic Beverages Except Beer Confusable with BELL TOWER for Beer, Says TTAB
• MOSAIC Opposer Fails to Prove Relatedness Between Vocational Training and its Entertainment Website
• TTABlog Test: Is APPARITION Confusable with PHANTOM for Wine? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test? Is ELEMENTAL BEAUTY for Skincare Products Confusable with BEAUTY IS ELEMENTAL for Nutritional Supplements? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Are Clothing and Perfume Related Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Are Clothing and Sunglasses Related Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
• Differences in Goods/Services Yield Dismissal of MISS BUSINESS/MS. BUSINESS Section 2(d) Opposition
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• Rejecting Strategic Partners Argument, TTAB Affirms 2d Refusal of IN HARMONY WITH NATURE for On-line Sale of Personal Care Products
• TTAB Overturns 2d Refusal of "SIDECAR SLIDER BAR" for Restaurant and Bar Services Due to Extensive Third-Party Use of "SIDECAR"
• Precedential No. 7: Opposer Fails to Prove Distinctiveness of its Common Law Mark, Loses 2d Opposition on Priority
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: Is MAYELA Confusable with MAYA for Wine? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is "LEFT RIGHT MIDDLE" Confusable with "LEFT CENTER RIGHT & Design" for Dice Games? [No]
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• DANKEES Confusable with YANKEES for Clothing, Says TTAB
• TTABlog Test: Is BUFFALO CITY for Alcoholic Beverages Confusable with BUFFALO TRACE for Bourbon? [Yes]

• On Remand, TTAB Sustains Cognac Institute's Section 2(d) Opposition to COLOGNE & COGNAC ENTERTAINMENT
• TTABlog Test: Is SEXTO for Alcoholic Beverages Confusable with THE SEXTON for Whiskey? [No]
• TTABlog Test: Are Mugs and Drinking Straw Cleaning Brushes Related Under Section 2(d)?
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• Proof of One Incident of Actual Confusion Factors Into TTAB's Granting of Petition to Cancel ZEROLIQUID Registration for Water Filters
• TTAB Affirms Five Refusals of SHYFT Marks for Beer and Flavored Malt Beverages: Confusable with SHIFT for Wine
• TTABlog Test: Is BREAK OUT THE BANDIDO Confusable with BANDIT for Overlapping Alcoholic Beverages?

Section 2(e)(1) - Mere Descriptiveness:

• TTABlog Test: Is BATTLE ROYALE GOLF Merely Descriptive of Golf Games? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is "GREEN COLLECTIVE" Merely Descriptive of Kitchen Utensils? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is WORLDWIDECRYPTO Merely Descriptive of Cryptocurrency Exchange Services? [Yes]
• TTAB Upholds Mere Descriptiveness Refusal of "THE TRAVELING PAWTOGRAPHERS" for Pet Portrait Photography Services
• Federal Court (E.D. Va.) Reverses TTAB Decision: Apple's REALITY COMPOSER and REALITY CONVERTER Not Merely Descriptive of Developer Software
• TTABlog Test: Is TENNISOS Merely Descriptive of Robotic Systems Software Platforms? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is GHOSTWRITTEN INC. Merely Descriptive of Publication of E-books and Blog Posts [No]
• TTABlog Test: Is NATIVE NATIONS CANNABIS Merely Descriptive of Hemp-Containing Cosmetics? [No]
• TTABlog Test: Three Recent Section 2(e)(1) Mere Descriptiveness Appeals - How Did They Turn Out?

Section 2(e)(2) - Geographical Descriptiveness:

• TTAB Reverses 2(e)(2) Geographical Descriptiveness Refusal of BUCKEYE CUSTOM E-BIKES

Section 2(f) - Acquired Distinctiveness:

• Despite 18 years of Sales, LED Configuration Lacks Acquired Distinctiveness, Says TTAB

Failure-to-Function:

• CAFC Vacates and Remands TTAB's Affirmance of F**K Failure-to-Function Refusal Due to Lack of Clarity
• BOSTON STRONG Fails to Function as a Service Mark for Volley Ball Entertainment, Says TTAB
• STROLL TO THE POLLS Fails to Function as a Trademark for Clothing, Says TTAB

Genericness:

• TTAB Grants Summary Judgment Motion, Tossing Out Genericness, Section 2(b), and Fraud Claims
• TTAB Sustains Genericness Opposition to MLD FAMILY for Metachromatic Leukodystrophy (MLD) Advocacy
• VETEMENTS Applicant Files Certiorari Petition Seeking Reversal of Genericness Refusal Under Doctrine of Foreign Equivalents

Lack of Bona Fide Intent:

• TTAB Sustains Disney's Opposition to OSWALD THE RABBIT for Movie and Play Production Due to Lack of Bona Fide Intent

Section 15(6) Nonuse Cancellation:

• DESPACITO Registrant Defeats Section 14(6) Claim by Proving Excusable Nonuse

Discovery/Evidence/Procedure:

• No Evidence = No Cancellation of Registration for CASUAL COMFORT for Pillows
• USPTO Trademark Alert: TTAB Changes Deadline for Answer in Board Proceeding to 60 Days
• TTAB Allows Amendment of Admission Responses but Grants Motion for Summary Judgment for Lack of Bona Fide Intent
• Oops! Opposer Fails to Prove Statutory Standing: Submitting Ordinary Copy of Registration Not Enough
• Precedential No. 6: TTAB Refuses to Add Affirmative Defense of Abandonment but Allows Addition as Counterclaims

CAFC Decisions:

• CAFC Reverses and Remands ASPIRE BANK Opposition for Reconsideration of First and Sixth DuPont Factors
• CAFC Vacates and Remands TTAB's Affirmance of F**K Failure-to-Function Refusal Due to Lack of Clarity
• CAFC Reverses TTAB: KIST is Confusable with SUNKIST for Soft Drinks
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: YUCATAN SHRIMP is Merely Descriptive of Prepared Shrimp Dish

Recommended Reading:

• Recommended Reading: The Trademark Reporter, July-August 2025 Issue

Other:

• Morgan & Morgan Claims Fair Use of Steamboat Willie Cartoon Adaptation in its Advertisement
• Current Roster of TTAB Administrative Trademark Judges
• TTAB Posts September 2025 Hearing Schedule
• TTAB Posts August 2025 Hearing Schedule

Text © John L. Welch 2025.

TTABlog Quarterly Index: April - June 2025

E-mail subscriptions to the TTABlog are available. Just enter your e-mail address in the box on the right to receive a daily update via Feedblitz. Please report any broken or inoperative links, as well as any errors and omissions, to the TTABlogger at jwelch at wolfgreenfield.com.

Section 2(a) - False Suggestion of a Connection:

• USPTO Fails to Prove Section 2(a) False Connection of ENAIRA with the Central Bank of Nigeria
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: US SPACE FORCE Falsely Suggests a Connection with the United States

Section 2(d) - Likelihood of Confusion:

• WYHA? TTAB Finds VITAWHEY Confusable with VITAWAYS for Dietary and Nutritional Supplements
• TTABlog Test: Are Jewelry and Underwear Related Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
• Prior Registration Under 13th DuPont Factor Fails to Save RAIN DANCER From Section 2(d) Refusal
• TTABlog Test: Are These Two Word-And-Design Marks Confusable for Keys and Key Blanks?
• TTAB Finds VORSPRUNG for Electric Vehicle Charging Stations Confusable with VORSPRUNG DURCH TEKNIK for Land Vehicles
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• Yankees Win! TTAB Sustains Section 2(d) Opposition to NYC NEW YORK CANNABIS & Design for Clothing
• TTABlog Test: Are Golf Simulator Services Related to Restaurant Services Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
• Third-Party Registrations and Uses Yield TTAB Reversal of Section 2(d) Refusal
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• TTABlog Test: Are Leather Bags Related to Cosmetics Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• TTAB Dismisses THOR Opposition, Finding Boats Unrelated to Recreational Vehicles: 34 Pairs of Third-Party Registrations Proved Decisive
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?

• TTABlog Test: Is MONSTER STRAW for Drinking Straws Confusable with MONSTER for Energy Drinks? [Yes]
• Professor J. Thomas McCarthy: "What is the 'Zone of Natural Expansion' Doctrine?"
• TTAB Partially Grants GUIDEON Cancellation Petition but Rejects Zone-of-Natural-Expansion Claim
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: CHICKEN SCRATCH for Beer is Confusable with CHICKEN SCRATCH for Restaurant Services
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?

Section 2(e)(1) - Mere Descriptiveness:

• TTABlog Test: Is "USNA" Merely Descriptive of Cosmetics? [Yes]
• POWER CAPSULE and POWER TUNNEL Merely Descriptive of Energy Storage Containers, Says TTAB
• WYHA? TTAB Finds DOCRETENTION Merely Descriptive of Document Retention Software
• TTABlog Test: Is PIZZACCIA Merely Descriptive of Pizza and Cheese? [Yes]
• SWIPE LEFT Merely Descriptive of, and Fails-to-Function as a Source Indicator for, Matchmaking Software, Says TTAB
• TTABlog Test: Is BLADE Merely Descriptive of Hammers for Hammer Mill Machines? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is UNITED STATES COAST GUARD Merely Descriptive of Employment Counseling and Recruiting Services? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(e)(1) Mere Descriptiveness/Disclaimer Refusals Was/Were Reversed?

Section 2(e)(5) - Functionality:

• TTAB Affirms Another Section 2(e)(5) Functionality Refusal: Beach Canopy

Abandonment/Nonuse/Specimen of Use:

• Providing Warranty Services With One's Own Goods is not a Recognizable Service Under the Trademark Act
• TTABlog Test: Is this Trademark Mutilation?
• TTABlog Test: Do You Recognize Trademark Mutilation When You See It?
• TTAB Grants HALFANIMAL Cancellation Petition on the Ground of Abandonment

Dilution:

• Two Dilution Claims: TTAB Finds "IVY LEAGUE" to be Famous, But Not "ASUS"

Failure-to-Function:

• TTAB Affirms Failure-to-Function Refusal of YOUR BEST CHOICE for Educational Services
• TTAB Affirms Failure-to-Function Refusal of Certification Badges for Completion of Skills Evaluation Courses
• SWIPE LEFT Merely Descriptive of, and Fails-to-Function as a Source Indicator for, Matchmaking Software, Says TTAB

Genericness:

• CAFC Affirms TTAB's VETEMENTS Genericness Ruling
• TTAB Finds SLEEP HEADPHONES to be Generic for . . . . Guess What?
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: Dark Green Color is Generic for Chloroprene Medical Examination Gloves
• TTABlog Test: Is HEELS Generic for Medicated Skin Care Cream?

Lack of Bona Fide Intent:

• Three Recent TTAB Inter Partes Decisions: a Mixed Bag of Defeats for the Plaintiffs
• Precedential No. 4: TTAB Sustains Opposition to CUADRA for Alcoholic Beverage Due to Lack of Bona Fide Intent

Pan-American Convention:

• E.D. Va. Affirms TTAB Decision Ordering Cancellation of two General Cigar Registrations for "COHIBA" Under Pan-Am Convention

Discovery/Evidence/Procedure:

• Three Recent TTAB Inter Partes Decisions: a Mixed Bag of Defeats for the Plaintiffs
• Precedential No. 5: TTAB Will Not Accept Incorporation-By-Reference of An Appellant's Prosecution Arguments
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: Mere Consumer Curtin Lacked Statutory Standing to Oppose RAPUNZEL for Dolls
• Petitioner Failed to Prove "Standing" for Cancellation of KINNEY SHOES Registration
• TTAB Dismisses LIVE RESIN Oppositions Under Rule 2.132(a) for Failure to Prosecute

CAFC Decisions:

• CAFC Reverses TTAB - Remands ECHO D’ANGÉLUS Opposition Due to Lack of Substantial Evidence Supporting Dismissal
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: Mere Consumer Curtin Lacked Statutory Standing to Oppose RAPUNZEL for Dolls
• CAFC Affirms TTAB's VETEMENTS Genericness Ruling
• CAFC Overturns TTAB Dismissal of SFERA Opposition, Remanding for Reconsideration of1st and 2nd DuPont Factors
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: US SPACE FORCE Falsely Suggests a Connection with the United States
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: Dark Green Color is Generic for Chloroprene Medical Examination Gloves
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: CHICKEN SCRATCH for Beer is Confusable with CHICKEN SCRATCH for Restaurant Services
• CAFC Upholds TTAB Dismissal of "fleur-de-lis" Cancellation Petition Due to Lack of Standing
• CAFC Affirms TTAB Dismissal of IVOTERS Opposition Due to Failure to Prove Acquired Distinctiveness (Priority) of Pleaded Marks

Recommended Reading:

• Recommended Reading: The Trademark Reporter, May-June 2025 Issue
• Ted Davis: "Federal Court and Trademark Trial and Appeal Board Review"
• The Trademark Reporter's 2025 "Annual Review of European Trademark Law"
• Professor J. Thomas McCarthy: "What is the 'Zone of Natural Expansion' Doctrine?"
• Recommended Reading: Dustin Marlan, "Servicing Trade Dress: Demystifying the Tertium Quid"

Other:

• Christina Hieber Named TTAB Acting Chief Administrative Trademark Judge
• Updated Roster of TTAB Administrative Trademark Judges
• TTAB Posts May 2025 Hearing Schedule
• Trademark Reporter: Call for Submissions for Theme Issue on Third-Party Liability and Related IP and Product Disputes
• TTAB Posts April 2025 Hearing Schedule

Text © John L. Welch 2025.

TTABlog Quarterly Index: January - March 2025

E-mail subscriptions to the TTABlog are available. Just enter your e-mail address in the box on the right to receive a daily update via Feedblitz. Please report any broken or inoperative links, as well as any errors and omissions, to the TTABlogger at jwelch at wolfgreenfield.com.

Section 2(a) Deceptiveness:

• TTABlog Test: Is ECOTWEED Deceptive for "Footwear made of a Tweed-like Material"? [Yes]

Section 2(c) - Consent of Living Individual:

• TTAB Upholds Four Section 2(c) Refusals of Anti-Trump Marks Due to Lack of Consent

Section 2(d) - Likelihood of Confusion:

• TTABlog Test: Is KINGS ARMOR Confusable with UNDER ARMOUR for Clothing?
• TTABlog Test: Are Sexual Arousal Supplements Related to Hair Care Products Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Is STEED COMPANY Confusable with CORCEL for Clothing? [Yes]
• TTAB Upholds 2(d) and 2(e)(4) Bifusal of WYSE LONDON for Clothing
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTAB Denies Section 2(d) Cancellation Petition due to Unconvincing Testimony Regarding Priority
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• Finding Restaurant Services Related to Paper Food Containers, TTAB Sustains DON'T MESS WITH TEX-MEX Opposition
• TTABlog Test: Is CLEANFACE Confusable with DR.BELMEUR CLEAN FACE for Beauty Products? [No]
• TTABlog Test: Are Educational Services for Incarcerated Individuals Related to Legal Services Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Are Cosmetics Related to Bottled Water for Section 2(d) Purposes?
• TTABlog Test: Are Pizza Parlors and Baked Goods Related Under Section 2(d)? [Yes]

• RTC RICH TRAPPERS CLUB Logo Not Confusable with RTC for Clothing, Says TTAB
• Eleven Third-Party Uses of "Cowbell" Not Enough to Overcome Cited COWBELL CREAM ALE Registration
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• TTAB Reverses Section 2(d) Refusal of "12 & Design" for Cosmetics Due to Third-Party Registration Evidence
• TTAB Reverses USPTO's Section 2(d) Refusal of PBE AWARDS & Design for Marketing Award Services
• E.D. Va. Reverses TTAB's Precedential Decision in HME Opposition, Orders USPTO to Issue Registration
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out
• TTAB Reverses Section 2(d) Refusal of FITO for Seeds Due to Dissimilarity of Marks and 13th DuPont Factor (Strategic Partners)
• Opposer Proves Prior Use of Common Law REVOLUTION JEWELRY WORKS Marks, Wins Opposition Battle
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals Turn Out?
• In 2024, What Was The Rate of TTAB Affirmance of Section 2(d) Refusals to Register?

Section 2(e)(1) - Mere Descriptiveness:

• TTABlog Test: How Did These Recent Section 2(e)(1) Mere Descriptiveness Appeals Turn Out?
• In 2024, How Often Did the TTAB Affirm Section 2(e)(1) Mere Descriptiveness/Disclaimer Refusals?
• Precedential No. 30: Illustration of Block Puzzle Merely Descriptive of Computer Game Software, Says TTAB

Section 2(e)(4) - Primarily Merely a Surname:

• TTAB Upholds 2(d) and 2(e)(4) Bifusal of WYSE LONDON for Clothing
• TTABlog Test: Is SELECT BY LANDRY'S Primarily Merely a Surname for a Customer Reward Program?

Section 2(e)(5) - Functionality:

• TTAB Lets Stand Bifusal of Leveling Leg Configuration: De Jure Functional and Non-Distinctive
• TTAB Affirms 2e5 Functionality Refusal of Fire Extinguisher Pressure Gauge Configuration, Despite Applicant's Design Patent
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: Pink Color De Jure Functional for Hip Joint Implants
• Precedential No. 1: TTAB Upholds USPTO Objections to Over-Inclusive Drawings for Watch Configuration Marks

Section 2(f) - Acquired Distinctiveness:

• Precedential No. 1: TTAB Upholds USPTO Objections to Over-Inclusive Drawings for Watch Configuration Marks

Section 14(3) - Misrepresentation of Source:

• Precedential No. 2: TTAB Sustains Section 14(3) Opposition to LA MONTSERRATINA for Meat Products Based on Reputation in USA Without Use

Abandonment/Nonuse/Specimen of Use:

• TTAB Finds "RUFFAREE" T-Shirt Specimen Acceptable for Dog Park Services
• TTAB Denies "DISORDERLY FASHION" Nonuse Cancellation Petition: It's Hard to Prove a Negative

Dilution:

• PANERA Fails to Prove Fame Before Applicant's First Use Date, TTAB Dismisses Opposition to PANERALUX for Unrelated Products
• Porn Star Name GIGI DIOR Dilutes-by-Blurring Famous DIOR Mark

Failure-to-Function:

• BON VOYAGE Fails to Function as a Trademark for Travel Pillows, Sinking Cancellation Petitioner's 2(d) Claim

Fraud:

• On Remand, Great Concepts Escapes With TTAB Wrist Slap for its Fraudulent Section 15 Declaration

Genericness:

• TTABlog Test: Is MUSH Generic for Oat-Based Cereals? [Yes]
• TTAB Finds "BRILLIANT ROSE" Generic for . . . Guess What?
• TTAB Finds MENTCHEES Generic for .... Guess What?

Non-ownership:

• Applicant Contractually Barred from Using Mark in 11 Metro Areas Still Entitled to Registration
• On Summary Judgment TTAB Sustains Opposition: Applicant Merely Re-packaged Branded Goods and so Does Not Own the Mark
• TTAB Grants Petition to Cancel VIVACE Registration for Microneedling Device: Manufacturer Owns the Mark, Not Distributor

Prosecution Issues:

• Precedential No. 1: TTAB Upholds USPTO Objections to Over-Inclusive Drawings for Watch Configuration Marks

Discovery/Evidence/Procedure:

• Precedential No. 3: Dismissal with Prejudice but Without Judgment Suffices for Claim Preclusion Defense
• Res Judicata Thwarts Applicant Seeking to End Run Prior Opposition by Limiting Services in Second Applications

CAFC Decisions:

• CAFC Affirms TTAB's MONEY MART Decision, Confirming that Zone of Natural Expansion Doctrine Applies Only Defensively
• CAFC Affirms TTAB's Dismissal of BULLSHINE FIREBULL Opposition Despite Commercial Strength of FIREBALL for Whisky
• CAFC Hears Oral Arguments in FUCK and RAPUNZEL Appeals
• CAFC Affirms TTAB: Pink Color De Jure Functional for Hip Joint Implants

Other:

• Current Roster of TTAB Judges
• The Trademark Reporter's 2025 "Annual Review" of U.S. Trademark Cases
• TTAB Posts March 2025 Hearing Schedule
• Three Recent Inter Partes Proceedings: The Bigger They Are ....
• TTAB Posts February 2025 Hearing Schedule
• TTAB Chief Judge Gerard F. Rogers Retires; Thomas V. Shaw Appointed Acting Chief Judge
• The Top Ten TTAB Decisions of 2024 (Part II)
• The Top Ten TTAB Decisions of 2024 (Part I)

Text © John L. Welch 2025.

2024 Precedential Decisions

E-mail subscriptions to the TTABlog are available. Just enter your e-mail address in the box on the right to receive a daily update via Feedblitz. You may also follow the TTABlog on Twitter: @TTABlog.


Section 2(a) - False Suggestion of a Connection:

• Precedential No. 11: TTAB Upholds 2(a) False Connection Refusal of LEATHERNECKS for Motorcycle Club Membership

Section 2(d) - Likelihood of Confusion:

• Precedential No. 28: TRIPLEYE Not Confusable With 3RD EYE for Optical Monitoring Software and Services, Says TTAB
• Precedential No. 25: TTAB Awards Priority to Opposer over Its Employee, Sustains Opposition to DISTRICT OF FASHION Mark
• Precedential No. 20: Supplemental Registration for PERMITS.COM Cancelled by Prior User of PERMIT.COM Despite No Acquired Distinctiveness
• Precedential No. 19: Red-White-and-Blue Mark Not Confusable with Red-Top Mark for Fence Posts, Says TTAB
• Precedential No. 18 (Part II): TTAB Grants Petition to Cancel BLOOKE Registration for Bicycles
• Precedential No. 15: TTAB Affirms Section 2(d) Refusal of UPC for Computer Components, Rejecting "Something More" Requirement When Only Goods are Involved
• Precedential No. 5: TTAB Finds SAGEFORTH Confusable With SAGE CENTRAL for Medical Information Services, Dismisses Section 18 Counterclaim Without Prejudice
• Precedential No. 1: TTAB Orders Cancellation of CAPTAIN CANNABIS Registration for Comic Books: Petitioner Proved Priority By Use Analogous to Trademark Use

Section 2(e)(1) - Mere Descriptiveness:

• Precedential No. 30: Illustration of Block Puzzle Merely Descriptive of Computer Game Software, Says TTAB
• Precedential No. 13: TTAB Reverses Requirement to Disclaim "ARCHITECT" in KORN FERRY ARCHITECT for HR Services
• Precedential No. 4: TTAB Finds "ZPILE" Merely Descriptive of Metal Sheet Piles

Section 2(f) - Acquired Distinctivenss:

• Precedential No. 2: TTAB Affirms Refusal to Register Proposed Multi-Color Mark for Breakfast Cereals

Failure-to-Function/Specimen of Use:

• Precedential No. 2: TTAB Affirms Refusal to Register Proposed Multi-Color Mark for Breakfast Cereals

Fraud:

• Precedential No. 18 (Part I): Fraud! TTAB Grants Petition to Cancel BLOOKE Registration for Bicycles

Use/Nonuse:

• Precedential No. 18 (Part II): TTAB Grants Petition to Cancel BLOOKE Registration for Bicycles - Nonuse
• Precedential No. 17: TTAB Rules that Retail Offering of One's Own Goods Qualifies as a "Service" Under the Trademark Act
• Precedential No. 16: "GABBY'S TABLE" Specimen Fails to Show Use of Mark for Recited On-Line Store Services
• Precedential No. 14: TTAB Affirms Two Expungement Decisions Based on Nonuse of SMARTLOCK for Evaporative Air Coolers

Discovery/Evidence/Procedure:

• Precedential No. 29: USPTO Has Inherent Authority to Correct its Error by Cancelling Inadvertently Issued Registration
• Precedential No. 26: TTAB Denies Motion to Compel: Responding without Objection to First Set of Discovery Requests does not Preclude Excessiveness Objection to Second Set
• Precedential No. 24: TTAB Rejects Law School Amicus Brief, Denies Partial Summary Judgment, and Tosses Out Six Affirmative Defenses
• Precedential No. 23: TTAB Refuses to Grant Partial Summary Judgment Against Applicant Who Doesn't Own the Mark
• Precedential No. 22: Failure to Respond to Requests for Admissions Leads to Cancelled Registration
• Precedential No. 21: TTAB Grants Motion to Bifurcate VELCRO Cancellation into two Phases
• Precedential No. 12: TTAB Rejects Sovereign Immunity Claim in Opposition to Virginia College System Marks
• Precedential No. 10: TTAB Denies Section 18 Petition to Restrict Beer Registration to Micro-Brewed Craft Beer

• Precedential No. 9: TTAB Denies HOLLYWOOD HOTEL Summary Judgment Motion, Finding No Claim Preclusion
• Precedential No. 8: TTAB Strikes "Trademark Bullying" Affirmative Defense in DOOR DABZ Opposition
• Precedential No. 7: TTAB Dismisses Cancellation Proceeding as Moot After Registrant Fails to File Section 8 Declaration
• Precedential No. 6: TTAB Denies Meta Platforms' Motion to Dismiss META Opposition on Timing and Standing Grounds
• Precedential No. 3: TTAB Rules that a Cancellation Petition Filed During Grace Period is Mooted If Section 8 Declaration Is Not Filed

Pan-American Convention:

• Precedential No. 27: TTAB Dismisses Empresa Cubana's Pan-Am Article 8 Claim, But With Leave To Re-Plead

Text Copyright John L. Welch 2024.

TTABlog Quarterly Index: October - December 2024

E-mail subscriptions to the TTABlog are available. Just enter your e-mail address in the box on the right to receive a daily update via Feedblitz. Please report any broken or inoperative links, as well as any errors and omissions, to the TTABlogger at jwelch at wolfgreenfield.com.

Section 2(d) - Likelihood of Confusion:

• TTABlog Test: Three Recent Section 2(d) Appeals - How Did They Turn Out?
• Heck Freezes Over: USPTO Fails to Prove Gin Related to Beer Under Section 2(d)
• TTABlog Test: Three Section 2(d) Appeals - Affirmed or Reversed?
• TTABlog Test: Is SWAG GOLF for Clothing Confusable with SWAG for Belt Buckles? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: Three Recent Section 2(d) Oppositions - Which Was/Were Dismissed?
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• JERSEY GIRL WHISKEY for Distilled Spirits Confusable with JERSEY GIRL for Beer and Wine, Says TTAB

• Another Strategic Partners Argument Fails: TTAB Affirms Refusal of "REACH & Design" for Vehicle Parts
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• Precedential No. 28: TRIPLEYE Not Confusable With 3RD EYE for Optical Monitoring Software and Services, Says TTAB
• TTAB Affirms Refusal of ENDURELITE in view of ENDUROLETE for Supplements, Rejecting Strategic Partners Argument
• TTABlog Test: Three Section 2(d) Appeals - Affirmed or Reversed?
• PICKWELL FARMS Confusable with PICTSWEET FARMS for Frozen Vegetables, Says TTAB
• TTABlog Test: Is AGAVE BLACK Confusable with BLACK AGAVE ESPECIAL for Skin Care Preparations? [Yes]

• TTABlog Test: Three Section 2(d) Appeals - Affirmed or Reversed?
• TTAB Reverses 2(d) Refusals of "SUN CHLORELLA" for Noodles Due to Crowded Field
• TTAB Finds Energy Drinks Related to Nutritional Supplements and Pickles
• TTABlog Test: Is This Word-and-Design Mark Confusable with PASION, Both for Cigars?
• TTABlog Test: Is FIJIAN SPICE COMPANY for Spices Confusable with FIJI for Drinking Water?
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Reversed on Appeal?
• TTABlog Test: Three Recent Section 2(d) Oppositions - How Do You Think They Came Out?
• Precedential No. 25: TTAB Awards Priority to Opposer over Its Employee, Sustains Opposition to DISTRICT OF FASHION Mark
• TTABlog Test: Three Section 2(d) Appeals - Affirmed or Reversed?
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?
• Consent Agreement Trumps Other DuPont Factors in Reversal of Section 2(d) Refusal
• TTABlog Test: Which of These Three Section 2(d) Refusals Was/Were Overturned on Appeal?

Section 2(e)(1) - Mere Descriptiveness:

• TTABlog Test: Is CERTIFIED SUGAR DADDY Merely Descriptive of Dating Software and Services? [Yes]
• TTABlog Test: How Did These Three Section 2(e)(1) Mere Descriptiveness Appeals Turn Out?
• TTABlog Test: Is PHYSICIANCARE Merely Descriptive of Software and Services Enabling Manufacturers to Deliver Information to Healthcare Providers?

• TTABlog Test: Must "CATTLE COMPANY" Be Disclaimed in "ROCK CREEK CATTLE COMPANY" for Real Estate Development Services?
• TTABlog Test: Must "Pop! Popcorn" Be Disclaimed in "Harry & David Pop! Popcorn" for Popcorn?

Section 2(f) - Acquired Distinctiveness:

• "Sunflower in Lapel" for Legal Services Lacks Acquired Distinctiveness, Says TTAB

Abandonment:

• In Second Stage of Cancellation Proceeding, TTAB Deems RASCAL HOUSE Abandoned for Restaurant Services

Failure to Function/Specimen of Use:

• "PROMATCH" for Drum Sticks Identifies a Process, Fails to Function as a Trademark
• TTAB Dubiously Finds that Vertical Light Beams atop Guitar-Shaped Building Fail to Function as a Source Indicator

• Does "FIRST LOOK" Fail to Function as a Source Indicator for Retail Membership Club Services?
• TTAB Dismisses FIRST YEAR DOWN Opposition: Failure-to-Function and Fraud Claims Fail
• TTAB Remands Failure-to-Function Refusal to USPTO for Consideration of Descriptiveness and Deceptiveness
• "SURVIVAL + Greek Cross Design" Fails to Function as a Trademark for First Aid Kits, Says TTAB
• Faulty Specimen Sinks YACHTLY Application for Yacht Chartering Services
• TTAB Wrestles with Applicant over Specimen Refusal: Guess Who Won?
• TTAB Affirms Refusal Because Specimens Show Use of Mark with Mobile App but not SAAS
• Ornamental Design on Jewelry and Clothing Fails to Function as a Trademark, Says TTAB

Fraud:

• TTAB Dismisses FIRST YEAR DOWN Opposition: Failure-to-Function and Fraud Claims Fail

Genericness:

• District Court Overturns USPTO's Genericness Refusal of SPECTACLES for "Smart Glasses"

Discovery/Evidence/Procedure:

• TTAB Dismisses 2d Opposition to VSS GLOBAL for Vedic Educational Services, But Remands Application for Consideration of Non-Distinctiveness
• Precedential No. 26: TTAB Denies Motion to Compel: Responding without Objection to First Set of Discovery Requests does not Preclude Excessiveness Objection to Second Set
• TTAB Denies Motion For Relief from Judgment After Applicant Failed to Appoint U.S. Counsel
• Precedential No. 24: TTAB Rejects Law School Amicus Brief, Denies Partial Summary Judgment, and Tosses Out Six Affirmative Defenses

Pan-American Convention:

• Precedential No. 27: TTAB Dismisses Empresa Cubana's Pan-Am Article 8 Claim, But With Leave To Re-Plead

Recommended Reading:

• Recommended Reading: The Trademark Reporter's Theme Issue on Artificial Intelligence
• Recommended Reading: The Trademark Reporter, September-October 2024 Issue
• Recommended Reading: Farmer and Bosnic: "2023-24 Trademarks Developments"

Other:

• TTAB Posts January 2025 Hearing Schedule
• Precedential No. 29: USPTO Has Inherent Authority to Correct its Error by Cancelling Inadvertently Issued Registration
• Three Recent Inter Partes "Disasters" - Don't let this Happen to You
• INTA Files Proposed Amicus Brief in Peju's Appeal: SDNY Erred in Applying Issue Preclusion Based on TTAB Decision
• Peju Pursues Appeal of SDNY Decision Misapplying B&B Hardware On Issue Preclusion

• TTAB Posts December 2024 Hearing Schedule
• November 2024 Update of TMEP Now Available
• TTABlog Celebrates 20th Anniversary !
• TTAB Posts November 2024 Hearing Schedule
• Replay of and Slides from Michael Keyes Webinar on "Avoiding Consumer Survey Pitfalls at the TTAB"
• TTABlog Webinar: Michael Keyes on "Avoiding Consumer Survey Pitfalls at the TTAB"

Text © John L. Welch 2024.